Personal and Commercial Insurance Agency in Central New York

For personal, business, and farm insurance, visit one of our four convenient locations in Oneonta, Chittenango, Richfield Springs, and Syracuse NY. Give Don Marsh Agency, Inc. a call at 607-432-8834 today!


Our Agency’s goal during this pandemic of COVID-19 is to continue to provide you with the highest quality of customer service, while doing our part to help stop the spread of this virus. In an effort to protect you, our staff, and their families, we’re transitioning to a new way of doing business for the time being.  On rotating basis members of our Team will be working from home and our doors will be locked.

As a reminder, most business with us can be conducted via phone and email! We encourage you to contact us remotely to make a payment, make a change on a policy, and even start a new one with a DocuSign signature.

As always, for any after hours service you can reach Nationwide directly at 1-877-669-6877, and for other carriers that your policies are with, we encourage you to reference your policy directly for their contact info.

We appreciate your understanding with these temporary changes, and encourage you to do all you can to assist with stopping COVID-19 as well. Please check our Facebook Page and Instagram for more updates. Stay healthy and safe, and let’s see this crisis come to a close as quickly as possible.

-The Don Marsh Agency

About Don Marsh Agency, Inc.

With more than 25 years of experience in the field, Don Marsh Agency, Inc. is dedicated to providing quality, individualized personal and commercial insurance policies to fit your lifestyle or business. We can accommodate all aspects of your insurance needs—there isn’t much we can’t do! Our expertise lies in finding the best insurance policies at affordable rates, providing our clients with the personalized coverage that they need without paying for anything that they don’t. Whether it’s your farm, your business, your home, your car, or your family’s financial security, protect what matters. We will provide the peace-of-mind you can only find by choosing a reputable insurance agency. We look forward to earning your business!

Are you fully protected? Our insurance policies can be tailored to your needs. We offer the following customizable products:


Hit the road knowing you’re safe and covered with a comprehensive auto insurance policy from Don Marsh Agency, Inc. Know exactly what you’re covered for, whether it’s a tap on the bumper or an unexpected collision.

Motorcycle, RV, and Boat

You work hard and should be able to play hard. Having a great insurance policy is important for both your safety and peace of mind—rely on us to provide it.

Homeowners and Renters

Whether it’s your first apartment or your family’s long-time home, do everything you can to protect one of your biggest investments. Get started with just one call to Don Marsh Agency, Inc.


No matter the size of your business, ensure your ventures and employees are fully protected. We will work with you to meet your company’s coverage needs and budget.


You are an integral part of the agricultural community, and we want to help set you up for success. Coverage includes livestock, farm employees, power failure, and more!

Find the coverage you’re looking for

Give us a call at 607-432-8834, we’d love to be of help you find the coverage you’re looking for. We are proud to serve individuals, businesses, and families in the Central New York area from our four convenient locations in Oneonta, Chittenago, Richfield Springs, and Syracuse.

Our Carriers

Products are underwritten by the issuing life insurance company. Insurance products are subject to underwriting guidelines, review and approval. Products and discounts not available to all persons in all states.